Understanding Aspect Ratio
What to do with those black bars
Steve Kindig has been an electronics enthusiast for over 30 years. He has written extensively about home and car A/V gear for Crutchfield since 1985. Steve is also a volunteer announcer in the folk department of community radio station WTJU, where he is one of the regular hosts of "Atlantic Weekly."
More from Steve Kindig
Are you one of those HDTV owners who are occasionally frustrated by the "black bars" that pop up on either side of the screen when you watch regular, non-high-definition shows? In this article, we'll explain why you see them and offer some solutions.
Aspect ratio basics
There are two common TV screen shapes that most folks will recognize — the squarish shape of old school tube TVs, and the widescreen shape of today's HDTVs. The term used to describe TV screen shape is "aspect ratio" — conventional TVs, and a few small-screen HDTVs, have a 4:3 aspect ratio; widescreen HDTVs have a 16:9 ratio.
TV shows will also have either a 4:3 or 16:9 ratio. While virtually all new HD shows are in 16:9, you'll still find some TV broadcasts in the conventional 4:3 ratio. And it's the difference in shape between those two ratios that can result in a "pillar boxed" picture — one with black columns standing to the left and right of the image — when you watch a conventional 4:3 program on your widescreen TV.
What you can do about the "black bars"
You may choose to keep the black bars on 4:3 sources, or decide to stretch or zoom that picture to fill the whole screen — it's a matter of personal preference. Nearly all recent widescreen TVs include one or more viewing modes that fill out the screen's width by stretching, zooming, or stretching and zooming the image. While most people find this effect acceptable for non-critical "background" viewing like the local news, many aren't thrilled when their favorite actors suddenly look noticeably stockier. See the images below to get an idea of how these picture adjustments might look.
4:3 image on a 16:9 screen
When 4:3 programs are displayed on a 16:9 screen, black or gray bars appear on the sides of the screen — the image is "pillar-boxed."
4:3 image stretched to fill a
4:3 image zoomed to fill a
16:9 image on a 16:9 screen
When you look at this widescreen version of the image we've been using to show 4:3, you can see just how much of the picture is lost with a 4:3 image.
We've found that zooming and stretching a picture works better for some shows than others. For example, a crisp Discovery Channel show can still look clear and detailed when zoomed or stretched; but lower-quality signals, such as reruns of older shows, can look noticeably more blurry and washed out. Of course, if you're someone who gets distracted by black bars on the side of your screen, you may prefer to go with a somewhat fuzzier picture. It's really up you.
If you do prefer a stretched or zoomed picture, then try to get familiar with the different aspect ratio modes your TV offers. Usually, there's a dedicated button on the remote, often labeled "Wide" or "Aspect," that lets you cycle through several options.
Still watch a lot of DVDs?
There are a couple of additional things worth noting if you watch a lot of DVDs. Namely, you'll find a range of aspect ratios and aspect ratio options. We've listed them below, along with some tips for watching them on a widescreen TV.
- Some discs have both "widescreen" (16:9 or wider) and "full screen" (4:3) aspect ratio options — you can choose the one that best fits your screen.
- Many discs offer only widescreen or full screen — make sure you shop accordingly.
- Some discs feature an "anamorphic" aspect ratio. These movies have extra lines of information inserted in a 4:3 signal, which the TV is then supposed to expand to fill a 16:9 screen. But, depending on the combination of your TV and player, it may not work properly. See our Troubleshooting section below for tips.
- Many DVD (and Blu-ray) movies feature aspect ratios that are wider than a 16:9 TV screen, such as 1.85:1 or 2.39:1. You'll especially notice the extra width of 2.39:1 movies because you'll see black bars on the top and bottom of the image — kind of like you would if you were watching a 16:9 letterboxed movie on an older 4:3 TV. These black bars don't bother most folks, but if you find them distracting, try cycling through your TV's aspect ratio modes to zoom or vertically stretch the image to fill the screen.
Troubleshooting aspect ratio problems
It's important to keep in mind that your TV isn't the only thing in your system that can affect aspect ratio. Your cable box, DVD or Blu-ray player, and other source components likely all have their own aspect ratio settings. And the TV show your cable box displays, or the movie in your disc player, also have their own set aspect ratios. If your TV, source component, and source material aren't all on the same page regarding aspect ratio, some pretty funky things can happen.
To avoid aspect ratio issues as much as possible, here's what we suggest:
- As you're setting up your video sources, be sure to go into the picture settings to menu and set it to the proper aspect ratio. The specific terms used in these menus differ, but for a widescreen TV you'll likely see something called "widescreen" or "16:9," for example.
|Use your disc player's setup menu to get a properly formatted picture on your TV screen.|
- Get to know your TV's aspect ratio controls. As we discussed before, today's TVs generally have a dedicated button on the remote that lets you quickly cycle through your options. Since the aspect ratio of the programming you're watching can change frequently — when you change the channel, for example, or even when a new show begins on the same channel — you should get comfortable using these controls to get the picture to your liking.
Below, you'll find some examples of common aspect ratio problems, along with some additional tips for remedying them.
|A 16:9 image on a screen set to 4:3.|
16:9 image on a screen set to 4:3
In this case, the source component is outputting a 16:9 signal, but the TV is displaying it in a 4:3 aspect ratio. You can see that the image has been squished horizontally to fit in this smaller area. We recommend cycling through your aspect ratio options to tell your TV to display a 16:9 image.
|A "letterbox" 16:9 image on a screen set to 4:3.|
"Letterbox" 16:9 image on a screen set to 4:3
The image in this example has a 16:9 aspect ratio, it's just not filling up the whole screen. Why not? The culprit in this case is often source material formatted for 4:3 TVs that's actually carrying a 16:9 program. So, the source material includes black bars on the top and bottom to make the 16:9 show fit the 4:3 space. Then, the source component sends that 4:3 signal to your TV — and it's either stretched or zoomed to fill the screen, or has pillar box bars on the left and right.
We've come across this problem before in a couple of different situations: (1) Occasionally, channels that normally broadcast shows in 16:9 mistakenly broadcast a 16:9 show in a 4:3 space; (2) Sometimes, DVDs labeled "anamorphic" will have this effect — even though they're supposed to fit a 16:9 screen, your disc player or TV may not handle the signal properly. In both cases, you may be able to correct the problem by adjusting aspect ratio settings on your cable/satellite box or disc player, but often the easiest (and possibly only) thing you can do is simply zoom the smaller 16:9 image to fill your larger 16:9 screen.
|A 4:3 image with a pillar box on a screen set to a 4:3 aspect ratio.|
4:3 image with pillar box on a screen set to 4:3
Here, the source component sent a pillar-boxed 4:3 image — in effect, an image made to fit a 16:9 screen. However, the TV is set to display a 4:3 image, so it adds a second set of black bars. We recommend cycling through your aspect ratio options to tell your TV to display a 16:9 image — either a pillar-boxed view, or a stretched or zoomed view to get rid of the black bars.